If a property was not sold before the time duration of the contract closing period between the property owner and the real estate agent ended, then that would be considered an expired listing. An expired listing is a helpful prospecting opportunity for real estate agents because the property owner has already attempted to sell the property but was unable to sell the property during the previous listing period. This can be because of pricing, marketing exposure, buyer demand, timing or other factors.
Agents can use expired listing calls and real estate appointment setting services to generate qualified conversations and listing opportunities. The goal here is to have a conversation that would uncover the seller’s motivation, discuss possible improvements to the listing strategy and set up an opportunity for a listing appointment.
What is an Expired Listing Cold Calling Script?
An expired listing cold calling script is a properly organized conversation template used by real estate agents to contact a homeowner whose property was previously listed for sale but couldn’t be sold for some reason during the previous listing period.
The script provides a practical framework for the conversation while allowing the agent to respond naturally to the seller. It shouldn’t sound like a memorized sales pitch. It should feel like a natural, spontaneous conversation. Real estate agents use cold calling scripts to generate more leads and appointments from the right decision-makers.
Key Information to Uncover
During an expired listing call, the agent can use discovery questions to understand:
- Why the property did not sell
- Whether the seller still wants to sell
- How many showings the property received
- Whether buyers submitted offers
- What feedback buyers provided
- Whether pricing was adjusted
- What the seller expects from a new listing
- Whether the seller is open to another listing agent
- What timeline the homeowner has in mind
These questions can help the agent understand the seller’s motivation before presenting a listing strategy.
What Should an Expired Listing Script Include?
A practical expired script can include 5 core elements:
| Script Element | Purpose |
| Friendly introduction | Builds rapport and lowers defenses |
| Listing confirmation | Confirms the property status is accurate |
| Discovery questions | Uncovers seller’s motivation and experience |
| Value statement | Positions the agent as a fresh solution |
| Call to action | Requests a listing appointment or consultation |
Agents need to understand what cold calling is in real estate to recognize what kind of approach is followed in expired listing scripts. Actually, it’s mostly the same discovery-first approach used across most prospecting calls.
Why Cold Calling Works for Expired Listings
The main distinction between a homeowner with an expired listing and one without an expired listing is that the former homeowner made a choice to sell the property and has attempted to sell it. Nevertheless, an expired listing does not indicate that the former homeowner wants to sell the house. The seller may no longer be interested in selling due to having changed their mind about the sale, waiting for a better offer, switching to a different real estate agent or because of personal reasons.
That’s why the primary goal should be finding out the core issue before asking for a listing agreement. To do this, cold calling allows agents to contact the homeowner directly, get to know what happened during the previous listing and find out whether there is still an opportunity.
Cold calling expired listings gives agents an opportunity to:
- Reach homeowners with previous selling intent
- Learn why the property did not sell
- Identify the seller’s current timeline
- Understand previous buyer feedback
- Discuss potential pricing or marketing improvements
- Introduce a new practical listing strategy
- Build rapport with the property owner
- Identify opportunities for a listing appointment
To get the most out of a cold call, agents should also consider the generally ideal time to cold call when planning outreach windows for expired listings and other seller prospects. Agents can position themselves as the solution to the previous failed listing if they approach the conversation with a collaborative and professional approach.
Expired Listing Cold Calling Script
Initial Introduction
The start should be brief and transparent. The agent should introduce themselves and the reason for the call without making the homeowner feel pressured or unsure.
Example:
Agent: “Hello {{Seller’s Name}}, this is {{Your Name}} with {{Brokerage Name}}. I’m calling because I noticed your home on {{Street/Area}} recently came off the market. I was just curious, are you still interested in selling the property?”
If the seller says yes, move into discovery questions instead of immediately presenting a full marketing pitch.
If the seller says they are unsure, ask an open-ended question to understand what changed.
Example: “I understand. Has your plan changed completely or are you still considering selling if the right opportunity comes along?”
Acknowledge the Seller’s Experience
Expired listing homeowners may have already received calls from several real estate agents. Acknowledging this can make the conversation feel more respectful.
Example: “Got it. I’m sure you’ve probably received a few calls already, so I’ll keep this brief. I was reviewing the listing and was curious about your experience. What do you think kept the home from selling?”
This question allows the homeowner to explain the situation in their own words.
Discovery Questions
Once the homeowner is willing to continue, use a few focused questions.
Example: “Just so I understand what happened, may I ask you a couple of quick questions?”
Then you can ask a few questions like these:
- “Did you get many showings while the home was listed?”
- “Were there any offers?”
- “What kind of feedback were buyers giving?”
- “Did you make any pricing changes?”
- “Were there particular concerns buyers mentioned?”
- “Are you still working toward a specific selling timeline?”
Avoid asking every question mechanically. Choose the questions that fit the seller’s responses.
Position a Fresh Listing Strategy
After gathering information, connect the homeowner’s situation to a possible new strategy.
Example: “That makes sense. Sometimes an expired listing comes down to pricing, marketing exposure or how the property was positioned. If we were to approach it again, I’d want to look at the market data, buyer activity and marketing plan before recommending the next step.”
This approach keeps the conversation focused on the property rather than making unsupported claims about the previous agent.
Ask for the Listing Appointment
The purpose of the call can be to secure a short consultation rather than trying to complete the entire listing presentation over the phone.
Example: “If I could show you a strategy based on the current market and your previous listing experience, would you be open to a quick 15-minute meeting?”
If the seller agrees, offer two reasonable scheduling options.
Example: “Great. What works better for you later today or tomorrow?”
This type of close gives the seller a clear next step without requiring them to make an immediate decision about signing a listing agreement.
Why This Script Works
This script focuses mainly on understanding the seller’s experience and avoids criticizing the previous agent. Also, it helps agents systematize the conversation around the seller’s experience, current motivation and potential next steps.
1. Starts With a Relevant Reason for Calling
The agent is contacting the homeowner because the property recently came off the market. By giving the reason behind the cold call, the context of the conversation is established instead of making it a random call.
2. Uses Discovery Questions
Questions help reveal information about the previous listing. It also makes the seller feel important and provides important insight into why the property did not sell.
Example: “What do you feel was the biggest challenge with the previous listing?”
The answer can help the agent decide whether to discuss pricing, marketing, presentation, buyer demand or another issue.
3. Avoid Attacking the Previous Agent
Criticizing another listing agent can trigger a negative reaction. Instead, focus on what happened and what could be done differently. To do this, agents should strengthen their approach by understanding how to actually build strong rapport through cold calling.
Example: “I’m not familiar with everything that happened during the previous listing, but I’d be happy to review the market data and see what options you may have.”
4. Creates a Reason for a Meeting
The agent does not need to deliver an entire listing presentation during a cold call. The initial goal can simply be to establish interest and schedule a consultation.
When to Use This Script
You can use this script when contacting property owners whose listing recently expired or was withdrawn from the multiple listing service. Timing depends on local MLS rules and brokerage prospecting policies. Before dialing, agents should also check applicable Do Not Call (DNC) lists and follow all relevant telemarketing regulations.
These calls usually work effectively when done after expiration, before the seller is contacted by a high volume of competing agents. If consistent follow-up and a reliable lead management system are combined, then it would keep the prospect list organized and improve conversion over time.
Expired listing calls are one part of a larger real estate prospecting strategy. Knowing how much real estate leads cost can help agents understand how different lead-generation methods fit into that strategy.
Common Expired Listing Objections (And What to Say)
Objection handling is where most expired listing calls are won or lost. Below are common pushbacks agents hear, along with response scripts.
“We’re relisting with the same agent.”
Response:
“That makes perfect sense. If you don’t mind me asking, what are they planning to do differently this time to help get the home sold?”
(Pause and listen.)
“I completely understand. Would you be open to hearing a quick second opinion before you make a final decision?”
“We’re not selling anymore.”
Response:
“I understand. If you don’t mind me asking, was it the experience of being on the market that changed your mind, or are you thinking about waiting until the market conditions are a little different?”
“We’re taking the home off the market for now.”
Response:
“I understand. Sometimes taking a step back gives homeowners a chance to reassess their options. If the right buyer came along at a price you were comfortable with, would you still consider selling?”
“We already have an agent.”
Response:
“Absolutely, I understand. I’m not looking to interfere with that relationship. I simply like to offer homeowners another perspective so they can feel confident about their options and decide what makes the most sense for them.”
Strong Closing Line
“Since the home didn’t sell the first time, I think it’s worth taking a thoughtful look at what could be done differently before putting it back on the market.
Would you be open to a quick conversation about a few strategies that may help improve the chances of getting it sold this time?”
Tips for Converting Expired Listings Into Appointments
Stay Positive About the Previous Agent
Avoid criticizing the previous agent. The homeowner may have had a positive relationship with that agent despite the property not selling. Instead, focus on identifying what could be improved in the selling strategy.
Example: “It sounds like you had a specific experience with the previous listing. I’d be happy to focus on what we could potentially adjust rather than revisiting what went wrong.”
Ask Questions First
Understanding the seller’s experience provides valuable insight into what they may need from a new agent. Discovery questions can provide more useful information than immediately presenting a long sales pitch.
Offer a Fresh Strategy
A seller with an expired listing may want to know what would be different from the previous time. The appropriate strategy depends on the property, market conditions, budget, seller objectives, and available buyer demand.
Example: “Rather than simply putting the property back on the MLS the same way, I’d first review the current market value, competing listings, buyer activity and the previous marketing approach.”
Call Quickly After the Listing Expires
Right timing is an important part of an expired listing prospecting system. The sooner the homeowner is contacted after their listing expires, the higher the chances of initiating a conversation before the other agents call them. Nevertheless, it is important for agents to adhere to appropriate contact rules, the current listing status, and the client’s circumstances.
Final Thoughts
Expired listings are a well-known source of leads for agents. These property owners already attempted to sell, which means the motivation often still exists. However, the seller’s current motivation can vary depending on the scenario, so agents should avoid assuming that every expired listing is ready to relist.
The ultimate objective of the cold call can be a short listing consultation rather than an immediate commitment. Agents can convert expired listings into listing appointments and successful sales by approaching the conversation professionally, asking thoughtful questions and presenting a new strategy.
How CallingAgency Can Help Real Estate Agents Get More Listing Appointments
Searching and contacting expired listing prospects can be time-consuming for real estate agents. CallingAgency helps agents reach property owners whose listings have expired and start relevant conversations about their current selling plans. Our team focuses on identifying potential prospects, handling initial outreach and creating opportunities for agents to follow up. This gives you more time to focus on qualified lead opportunities.
We support targeted cold calling, lead research and appointment setting to help agents connect with homeowners who may still be interested in selling. This organized prospecting process can help real estate agents spend less time searching for opportunities and more time speaking with potential sellers.