Contact Us

(888) 875-0799

Who Is Liable When An Outsourced Caller Breaks The TCPA?

Last Modified: November 18, 2026

Who Is Liable When An Outsourced Caller Breaks TCPA
Table of Contents

Ready to Build a Predictable Sales Pipeline?

Book a Free Strategy Call

Many businesses hire another company for cold calling to reach people interested in buying their products. They do it trusting the agency that they will follow all the legal rules when making phone calls. For example, you expect it not to make illegal calls or ignore people’s requests to stop calling.

Suppose a person tells the agency, “Please don’t call me again.” But the agency ignores this request and calls that person again.

What happens now? Who will get into legal trouble for making that unwanted call? Will it be your company, the agency, or both? The agency may be directly liable, and your business may be vicariously liable. Your business may be responsible, and the agency that made the call may also be responsible.

The agency itself can get into legal trouble because its employees made phone calls that broke the law. You hired the cold calling agency to make phone calls on behalf of your business. So, even though you didn’t personally make those calls, your business may also be held responsible. Now, let’s dig into the concept more.

Is the Agency Liable Too, Or Only You?

Both your business and the agency can be held liable for illegal calls. The agency actually makes the phone call. So, it is responsible for what it does. Even though you didn’t make the call, the agency made it for you. That’s why your business can also be punished.

In its 2013 DISH ruling, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) explained that two different parties can be involved in telemarketing. The telemarketer and the seller.

There are three situations where your business can also get into legal trouble because of the agency’s calls. These three situations’ legal names are:

3 Situations Where Business Becomes Liable of Calling

  • Actual authority: You directly tell the agency that it can make calls for your company.
  • Apparent authority: The customer believes the agency represents you.
  • Ratification: You know about the wrongdoing but still accept the work.

The person who received the illegal call can take legal action against both companies. If the agency gets punished, your business does not automatically escape punishment.

The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) is a US law that restricts certain types of unwanted calls and messages. For each TCPA violation, the penalty can be $500. If the court finds that the violation was intentional, the penalty can increase to $1,500 per violation.

Where The Risk Actually Sits In A B2B Campaign

Manual B2B calls are usually safer than automated calls. But that doesn’t mean manual cold calling is legal every time. Even a real person can break calling laws.

Your business can face risks if it calls protected numbers or breaks state laws. The main risks are:

Main Calling Risk in B2B Campaign

Mixed-use mobile numbers: This means a person uses the same phone number for their business and personal life. The Chennette v. Porch.com (2022) confirmed that a mobile number used for both business and personal purposes can be treated as a residential number under the relevant Do Not Call rules.

Ignoring requests to stop calling: Even if someone’s phone number is NOT registered on the Do Not Call list, that person can personally tell your agency to stop calling. The agency must write down or save the person’s request. After receiving the request, the agency must stop making covered calls within 10 business days. Then it must keep the information about the request for five years.

State telemarketing laws: Some states have their OWN additional rules for telemarketing calls, like calling hours, caller ID, and permission to call. For example, Florida Statute 501.059 sets rules for certain sales calls. It mainly regulates covered consumer sales calls, not every business-to-business call.

B2B vs B2C Outsourced Calling Risk

Campaign type Main rule Private lawsuit threshold Main risk
B2B live, manual dialing TCPA do-not-call rules when the number is residential More than 1 violating call in 12 months by or on behalf of the same entity Mixed-use numbers and missed opt-outs
B2B with artificial or prerecorded voice TCPA artificial or prerecorded voice restrictions A single prohibited call may support a claim Calls without required consent
B2C live, manual dialing Do-not-call rules and other telemarketing requirements More than 1 violating do-not-call call in 12 months Registry calls and ignored requests
B2C with an autodialer or prerecorded voice TCPA automated-call restrictions and do-not-call rules A single prohibited call may support a claim under the relevant rule Missing consent and unlawful calling technology

In Facebook v. Duguid (2021), the Supreme Court explained that an automatic calling system generally counts as an autodialer under the TCPA only if it has the capacity to use a random or sequential number generator to store or produce phone numbers to store or produce phone numbers.

If an agency saves 500 phone numbers in a computer and automatically calls those numbers, that alone does not mean it is using an autodialer under the TCPA. But for recorded or artificial voices, there are separate restrictions. These rules can apply even without an autodialer.

Under the TCPA statute, a person must receive at least TWO illegal Do Not Call calls within 12 months to bring a private lawsuit.

What Makes A Caller Count As Calling On Your Behalf?

A caller counts as calling when you give an agency permission to make calls for your company. Even if you don’t personally make the calls, your company may still be responsible.

The FCC explained four activities that can indicate that an agency is representing your business.

  1. You approve the cold calling scripts
  2. You provide customer data
  3. The agency uses your CRM
  4. The agency uses your company name

These four activities commonly happen in outsourced B2B calling. Just because you give an agency customer data or CRM access, it does not automatically mean you are legally responsible for every action of that agency. The court looks at the entire relationship, not just one activity.

There are three legal principles that help explain when your business may be responsible for an agency’s illegal calls:

  • Actual authority: You directly give permission to the agency to make calls for your company.
  • Apparent authority: Customers believe the agency represents you because of your actions.
  • Ratification: You discover the wrongdoing but still allow it to continue.

Even if you have a written agreement with the agency, that agreement does not protect your business from legal responsibility. The FCC explained this principle in its 2013 DISH Network decision.

Businesses may also need to register with the government before making certain sales calls. Some states require the agency, the seller, or both to register before making certain sales calls.

For example, in Salaiz v. VSC Operations (2024), a Texas federal court allowed a legal complaint against a seller to continue. It’s because the agency was accused of making calls without the required state registration. The seller was accused of directing important parts of the agency’s calling activities.

This suggested that the seller was closely involved in the calls. The seller also gave the agency the computer system used to save customer information. The court allowed the case to move forward. But it did not yet decide whether the seller was legally responsible.

When Are You Not Liable For The Agency’s Calls?

If an outside agency makes an illegal call, you are not automatically liable for that. There must be a legal connection between your business and the agency’s illegal calls for you to be blamed.

Whether you outsource cold calls or call-answering services, follow these steps:

  • Write clear rules for handling do-not-call requests.
  • Train your employees and outside agencies on how to follow telephone laws.
  • Keep a list of numbers that your business and agency are not allowed to call.
  • Check whether the agency actually follows your rules.
  • Keep records of your compliance work.
  • Stop illegal calls as soon as you discover them.

The TCPA gives your business a defense against certain do-not-call claims if you have sensible rules to prevent illegal calls. It gives businesses special protection in certain situations where an unwanted call happens by accident.

The TCPA allows you to defend yourself when you have reasonable rules and follow them properly. To qualify, you must have written procedures and keep a do-not-call list. Besides, you must use a National Do Not Call Registry copy, which should not be more than 31 days old.

The Royal Seas case (2022) shows why businesses must not ignore warning signs about illegal calls. Over one and a half years, Royal Seas received information from a lead company. It was connected to 2.1 million calls. There were doubts about whether some people had actually permitted being called.

Among the people who purchased cruises, 13% had phone numbers that did not match the phone numbers in the records. Royal Seas saw signs that something might be wrong with the calls. But it continued accepting possible customers from the lead company.

The Ninth Circuit reversed summary judgment for Royal Seas, finding a jury could decide it ratified the calls. A jury could decide that Royal Seas knew about the warning signs but ignored them. The court did not take Royal Seas’ court decision that it was legally responsible. It only allowed the legal claim to continue. That is not the same as finding the business guilty or liable.

Why The Agency’s Opt-Out Misses Count Against You

If your agency fails to stop calling someone who asked not to receive calls, your business may also get into trouble.

Here are some FCC rules that businesses must follow while calling:

  • Record every request to stop calls.
  • Stop calling that person within 10 working days.
  • Keep that person’s number on the list for 5 years so nobody calls them again.

Your employees and your outside human agency both make calls for your business. So, the law may count their calls together. Under the TCPA, if someone receives at least two illegal calls from your business within one year, they may take your business to court.

To avoid such circumstances, follow these techniques in your contact strategy:

  1. Use one do-not-call list for everyone.
  2. Share new requests with your agency quickly.
  3. Keep records showing when the list is updated.

Who Holds The Proof on a Calling Agency Campaign

The agency usually saves two types of information: lead sources and calling records. But your business should also save copies of them so that your business has its own proof and doesn’t have to depend only on the agency.

These saved documents and call records can help show that your agency followed the legal rules. Even though another company makes the calls for you, your business may also get into legal trouble if the agency breaks the law.

Typical Task Split in an Outsourced B2B Calling Campaign

Task Who usually does it Where the record sits
DNC Registry check Agency Records showing when numbers were checked
Internal do-not-call list Agency and seller Shared list of numbers that must not be called
Calling hours by time zone Agency Dialer settings and call logs
Dialer mode and voice tools Agency Dialer settings
Consent records, where needed Whoever collected consent Consent forms or recordings
State registration Agency and seller, depending on state law Registration documents
Call recordings and logs Agency Recordings and reports shared with clients

Before calling someone, the agency must check whether that person’s number is on the Do-Not-Call (DNC) list. This list contains the numbers of people who don’t want promotional calls. Your business should have proof that the agency checked the numbers before calling.

Conclusion

Your business can hire another company to call people and tell them about your products or services. But your business still has a responsibility to follow the law. If the agency breaks calling laws while calling for your business, your business may also face legal trouble.

That’s why before hiring an agency, how the economic agents make calls. Do they follow the law? And if a person asks not to receive calls, do they record that in the Do Not Call list?

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an indemnification clause enough to protect your business?

No, an indemnification clause is not enough to protect your business. If the agency breaks the law, your business may ask the agency to pay certain expenses. But it must have enough money to pay those expenses. If it has no money, its promise may not help you much. That’s why you shouldn’t blindly trust the agency. Check regularly what it is doing and save records of its phone calls.

Can you be sued for calls the agency made without telling you?

Yes, your business can sometimes be sued for calls the agency made without telling you. You hired the agency to make calls for your company. So, if it makes illegal calls on your behalf, your company may also be held responsible. Suppose you discover that your agency is making illegal calls. But you do nothing and allow it to continue. In that case, your business may also get into trouble.

Does the TCPA apply to B2B cold calls?

Yes, some TCPA rules apply to B2B cold calls. When a real person calls an ordinary business phone number, there are generally fewer US federal restrictions. But calling someone’s home phone can still violate the law. There are some US states that may have additional rules. And most calls made by one business to another business are not covered by this particular FTC telemarketing rule. Even when a business calls another business, it cannot give false information to make a sale.

Is a US-based agency safer than an offshore one for TCPA?

A US-based agency is not automatically safer than an offshore one for TCPA. Suppose an agency is located in Bangladesh but makes phone calls to people in America. It may still have to follow US calling laws. These can be for automatic dialling and prerecorded or artificial voices. But what matters is how easily you can communicate with the agency and get copies of its records.

CallingAgency Editorial Team

The CallingAgency editorial team writes about B2B cold calling, appointment setting, lead generation, SDR training, BANT qualification, and TCPA-compliant outreach. By combining sales development expertise with service-based marketing experience, the team produces clear, practical content that helps business owners, sales teams, and decision-makers simplify complex outbound sales topics.